top of page
Search

Autism: Can We Celebrate Neurodiversity Without Minimizing Disability?

Nov 9
5 min read


Lately, I've found myself thinking quite a bit about how we understand autism, how we talk about it, and perhaps most importantly, how we define it.


I've been reading Divergent Mind by Jenara Nerenberg, and I am thoroughly enjoying it. I appreciate the way she explores the history of neurodivergence, particularly in women, and challenges many of the assumptions we have historically made about what is considered typical, appropriate, or expected.


But I've also found myself sitting with some discomfort. One of the things I've been thinking about is the growing movement away from describing autism as a disorder, a deficit, or something that needs to be fixed. Instead, we increasingly hear autism described as a difference, an identity, or even a superpower.


I understand why this shift has happened. For a long time, autistic people have been viewed almost exclusively through a medical lens: what they cannot do, where they struggle, how they differ from their peers, and what needs to be corrected. There has been enormous harm in an approach that too often prioritizes appearing typical over feeling safe, understood, accepted, and supported.


Moving away from that thinking is important. Recognizing the strengths, perspectives, interests, creativity, and different ways of experiencing the world that can accompany autism is important. So is recognizing that many of the difficulties autistic people experience are not necessarily inherent to who they are, but are created or amplified by environments and expectations that don't accommodate their needs.


And yet, I find myself struggling with the idea of autism as a superpower.


In my clinical practice, I work with autistic children whose experiences of autism can look extraordinarily different. Some have remarkable abilities, intense interests, exceptional attention to particular details, or ways of thinking that offer perspectives others might miss. Others experience profound challenges with motor planning, communication, sensory processing, regulation, and the everyday demands of life.


I work with children who are non-speaking, children with significant dyspraxia, and children for whom seemingly simple everyday activities require enormous amounts of effort, support, and adaptation. Their challenges are not simply a consequence of an unaccommodating world. Some of them experience very real neurological differences that affect their ability to move through and participate in everyday life, even in environments where they are deeply loved, accepted, and supported.


And I don't want our efforts to celebrate neurodiversity to inadvertently minimize those experiences.

I worry that, in moving away from a deficit-based narrative, we can sometimes lose the language to acknowledge disability. That in trying to emphasize strengths, we can unintentionally overlook suffering, genuine limitations, and the need for substantial support.


I don't think we need to choose between recognizing someone's strengths and acknowledging their disability. Both can exist. A child can have an incredible mind, a wonderful sense of humour, a unique way of seeing the world, and extraordinary strengths, while also experiencing significant challenges that affect almost every aspect of daily life.


Is one diagnosis enough to describe such different experiences?


Another question I've been sitting with is whether autism, as we currently define it, is too broad a diagnostic umbrella.


Prior to the DSM-5 (published in 2013), the DSM-IV included five diagnoses under the broader category of Pervasive Developmental Disorders (PDD): Autistic Disorder, Asperger's Disorder, Pervasive Developmental Disorder – Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS), Childhood Disintegrative Disorder, and Rett's Disorder. With the introduction of the DSM-5, Autistic Disorder, Asperger's Disorder, PDD-NOS, and Childhood Disintegrative Disorder were brought together under one diagnosis: Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Rett's Disorder was removed as a separate diagnostic category, although individuals with Rett syndrome can also meet the criteria for ASD.

The intention was, in part, to recognize that autism presents in many different ways and that the boundaries between these previously separate diagnoses were not always clear. There is value in that approach. It recognizes that autism doesn't present in one predictable way and that people can have very different combinations of characteristics and support needs.


But I sometimes wonder whether we've stretched that umbrella so far that it no longer adequately communicates the extraordinary differences in neurological profiles, functional abilities, and support needs among the people who fall under it.


A person who is highly articulate, independently manages daily life, and experiences social and sensory differences has a very different lived experience from a person who is non-speaking, has significant motor-planning difficulties, requires extensive assistance with daily activities, and needs lifelong, intensive support.


Both deserve understanding, respect, accommodation, and acceptance. Neither experience should be considered more or less valid. But are we really describing the same thing in a way that is clinically meaningful?


I find myself hoping that future revisions of the DSM will offer a more nuanced way of differentiating autistic presentations. Not necessarily to recreate the old diagnostic categories or establish rigid hierarchies, but to better recognize the considerable differences in underlying profiles, functional impact, and support needs. A single spectrum can suggest a simple continuum, when the reality is much more complex. Perhaps we need a better way of describing the different dimensions of autism, rather than relying on one broad label to communicate so much.


But, the medical model limits our understanding of neurodivergence


Here is where I find myself in a bit of a contradiction. While I would welcome a more differentiated diagnostic framework, I also wish we could move further away from the medical model of understanding human differences.


The medical model has traditionally positioned the individual as the problem. We identify the disorder, describe the deficits, measure the ways someone deviates from typical development, and then try to remediate those differences. But human beings are so much more complicated than a diagnostic label.


A diagnosis can help us understand certain aspects of someone's experience. It can provide access to funding, services, accommodations, and support. It can offer families an explanation for things they've been trying to understand for years. But it cannot tell us who a child is. It cannot fully explain their nervous system, their sensory experiences, their relationships, their strengths, their interests, or what they need to feel safe and connected. And perhaps most importantly, it shouldn't dictate what we believe is possible for them.


I would love to see us move toward a way of understanding neurodevelopment that is less focused on categorizing people according to what is wrong with them, and more focused on understanding how their brains and bodies work, how they experience the world, where they encounter barriers, and what allows them to participate and thrive. That doesn't mean pretending disability doesn't exist. It doesn't mean denying the very real challenges that some people experience or the enormous amount of support some individuals and families need.

It means being able to hold both truths at once.


Is there more than one truth?


I don't have a neat conclusion to these thoughts. In fact, I think I'm becoming more comfortable with the idea that there may not be one.


I want us to celebrate neurodiversity without romanticizing disability. I want us to recognize strengths without feeling that we have to find a superpower in every diagnosis. I want us to acknowledge profound challenges without defining people by their limitations.


I want families to have access to the support and understanding they need without feeling that their child's difficulties must be minimized to fit into a more affirming narrative.


And I want autistic individuals to be seen as whole people, not as a collection of symptoms, deficits, exceptional abilities, or diagnostic criteria.


Perhaps the goal isn't to replace the language of disorder with the language of superpower. Perhaps it's to move beyond the idea that we need to define people primarily through either.

We can recognize difference. We can acknowledge disability. We can celebrate strengths. We can provide support. And we can do all of these things without contradiction.

 
 
 

Comments


I honour and respect the peoples and the lands of the Tla’amin Nation that I am grateful to work and live on. I am fully committed to study, embrace, and apply the Tla'amin Service Model in my work with all indigenous children and families.​

  • Instagram

©2024 by Nancy Van Zyl

Reg. OT (BC)

CHCPBC: AW4506

4552 Willingdon Ave, qathet | 604 200 6670

bottom of page